Neil Turner's Blog

Blogging about technology and randomness since 2002

Movable Type 3.0 Developer Edition review

I promised this a few days ago, so here it is – a review of Movable Type 3.0 Developer Edition. Screenshots are included – click on them to see them full size.

Upgrading

Six Apart, as always, has a good guide to upgrading. Moving from 2.661 to 3.0 involved uploading the new files, running the mt-check.cgi script again (since there are some new optional perl module requirements) and then running the upgrade script, both of which can then be deleted from the server. The mt-check script has now been styled so it looks much nicer.

The main menu

Main menu screen Once you have logged in, you will be presented with the new main screen. This is a big improvement – instead of each weblog having three links (add entry, manage and delete), there are 6 which give quicker access to other functions. The public URL of the blog is also given.
On the right, a news pane, which presumably syndicates from movabletype.org, gives you the latest news; some may say this is ‘calling home’ but it is useful, I suppose. The links that were on the right are now further down the page, and now use a more friendly lower-case font.

Creating a new entry

Edit entry screen This is the modified edit entry screen. The layout in MT3 is all controlled by stylesheets – there are no tables in here. This screenshot does show a minor bug – it still says ‘Create new entry’ even though I’ve just edited an existing one. Status messages now have a cream background.
Like all my screenshots, this was taken in Firefox in Windows XP, and as you can see the bold/italic/underline/URL buttons have finally made it over (they were an IE-only feature previously). This shot doesn’t show it, but the options at the bottom of the edit page have been re-organised and now look better.

Edit Entries

Edit entries screen This is the ‘Edit Entries’ screen. It isn’t much different to 2.661, so instead I’ll describe the new menu down the left side. Whereas the old one was a load of images, this one is a CSS list. The text is proper text now too, which should make translations much easier. New options are management screens for comments, trackbacks and registered commenters, which I’ll explain later.
It’s also perhaps worth pointing out that MT3 needs a 800×600 display as opposed to a 640×480 one. Thankfully this also means that those of us with larger resolutions don’t have to squint so hard at the screen now.

Edit Comments

Edit comments screen This is a new screen that comes as part of MT3’s new comment management system, and includes all recently received comments for all entries on that weblog. It’s quite like the mass comment deletion system that comes with MT-Blacklist, only this time integrated with the main application, and is a very welcome improvement. It does require some explaining though 🙂 .
The filter box allows you to filter the list by email address, name or IP address, so you can view all comments by a particular author. This makes removal of spam spanning multiple entries much easier. The magnifying glasses by particular entries, names and IP addresses will apply filters to that particular item. The Status column comes with the new comment registration system, and shows whether the comment has been approved or is awaiting moderation. Finally, if the poster has used Typekey, you can ban them if you don’t want them to continue commenting.
If you filter by IP address, a button to ban that IP address also appears – previously you would have to copy and paste the address into the IP banning screen.

Editing individual comments

Edit comment screen You can still edit individual comments, and the screen to do so has received an upgrade too. You can now search for other comments with the same name, email address, URL or IP address, and there’s a link to add a comment to the entry (which takes you to the public page). If the poster used Typekey then you can’t alter the name, email or URL provided, but a big red ‘Ban User’ button does appear. You can still alter the text of their comment though.

Editing Trackbacks

Edit trackbacks screen Another new feature to MT3. This is very similar to the mass comment editor, but for editing trackbacks. Again, you can apply a filter to the page – either by ping title, excerpt or source. You can also click on an IP address of a weblog that has pinged you and filter by that. You can’t edit the pings but you can delete them en masse and block IP addresses. Trackback spam isn’t a major problem but it may be in future, so this a good bit of forward-thinking from Six Apart.

Manage Commenters

Manage commenters screen The third new screen in this release allows you to manage commenters, albeit only those who have used Typekey to post. From here you can ban people or view their profile. You can’t ban people en masse yet though. And yes, that is Anil Dash in the screenshot.

Weblog Configuration

Comment Settings screen With new features comes new settings to control them, although there aren’t a huge number of new options. Archiving Preferences has a new option called ‘Use Old-Style Archive Links’ which is enabled by default on upgrades and disabled on new installs. In MT3, new weblogs default to the URL format “blogurl.com/archives/2004/05/entry_title.html”, instead of “blogurl.com/archives/000653.html”, this option lets you choose the old format if you wish.
The screenshot I’ve included features the new commenting options. The biggest change is comment moderation and registration, a la Typekey. You can select to have all new Typekey users to need approving before they can comment, or to have all non-Typekey comments to require moderation before they appear (previously you needed a hack to do this). The new options are explained well though.
All these new options does make the ‘Preferences’ page of Weblog Configuration very long – perhaps in a future release this could be split into multiple pages.
The Archive Files page in Config has been changed slightly and it’s now easier to create new archive templates.

Other new features

The emails that are sent when a new comment is posted now include an edit link, so you can modify or delete the comment much more easily. Previously, you needed MT-Blacklist for this. There’s also a nice new built-in template tag called <MTIfNonZero> which takes a parameter of a MT tag that outputs a value (such as the number of comments in an entry). You can combine this with <MTElse> so that you can display messages when there are no comments, for example. Before, you needed to MTIfComments or MTIfTrackbacks plugins.
As for templates, the default RSS 2.0 template is now a ‘non-funky’ version that doesn’t use any extra namespaces and simply uses native elements. It’s pretty much the same as this template provided by Brad Choate except it includes the <link> element for better backwards compatibility. An RSS 1.0 template is still provided, and neither of the two offer full entries, only excerpts. The Atom 0.3 feed is the only to include full entries.
Having used MT3 for nearly a week now it is starting to grow on me. Some of the improvements are very good, if a little less groundbreaking than what many were expecting. Hopefully the official release of MT3 will bring these big new features.

26 Comments

  1. I was going to write this, and now I don’t have to. Thanks Neil!
    Great review. I too had an easy upgrade. I have yet to add the new comment code though.

  2. Excellent Review

    Neil’s World – Movable Type 3.0 Developer Edition review…

  3. Well written. Been looking around for a decent review, so that was very useful.

  4. Movable Type 3.0 Review

    An enterprising young Neil Turner of York, United Kingdom has posted a review of the recently released Movable Type 3.0 Developers Edition. Neil steers far clear of the recent outcry (whining) about MT’s new licensing model (What? Pay for software?). …

  5. Cool, I made it into a screenshot! 🙂

  6. MT 3.0 Review

    Neil Turner has a review of MT 3.0 Developers Edition. Screenshots as well….

  7. MT3D reviewed

    Neil’s World: ‘I promised this a few days ago, so here it is – a review of Movable Type 3.0 Developer Edition. Screenshots are included – click on them to see them full size.’

  8. Movable Type 3.0 Screenshots

    Movable Type 3.0 Developer Edition review: Here’s a review of MT3 with something I’ve been looking for: lots of screenshots. The new interface is nice — very TypePad-ish….

  9. Thanks, duder. 😀

  10. MT3d Reviewed

    A review that is on the mark for Movable Type Version 3.0d [Neil’s World]…

  11. Movable Type 3.0: a review with screenshots

    It’s fair to say there’s been a fair bit of brouhaha following the announcement of Movable Type 3.0 Developer Edition, the latest version of arguably the most popular blogging platform, and with particular reference to its controversial pri…

  12. Upgrading to MT3.0D

    Site updated to MT3.0 Developers Release.

  13. http://www.rhapsodic.org/archives/2004_05.html#001803

    i just got back from a very long (and surprisingly enjoyable) staff lunch. i love when there is leftover food…

  14. Oh, thanks for the screenshots, I have been wondering about the new look for a while now.
    😀

  15. I can see you have comments working here. Did you have to do anything special? After installing last night, I was unable to get comments to work. My initial impressions are not that good. It really does seem like the old MT that costs money now.
    I also installed ExpressionEngine last night. Now there is a nice CMS. I haven’t spent much time with it yet, but so far I am very impressed.
    I posted my inital impressions over at my site but I will be expanding on them as I experiment further.

  16. MT 3.0 Reviewed

    I like Neil Turner’s review of Movable Type 3.0. This article shows several screenshots of very nice overview of the new publishing interface and features. As you can see the idea what I am doing with Movable tools on my…

  17. Revisión de Movable Type 3.0 Developer Edition

    El la bitácora de Loïc, leo que Neil Turner realiza una revisión de las características y novedades de la Developer Edition de Movable Type 3.0, que incluye capturas de pantalla. Movable Type 3.0 Developer Edition review: «Having used MT3 for

  18. Great review. Thanks! I was waiting for someone to start telling all of us their real experience with MT 3.0 as oppose to just opposing the licence structure.
    Have yet to decide whether to update or not.

  19. Movable Type 3.0

    The Movable Type 3.0 announcement came about when I was on vacation, so I missed it, but this is interesting development. Firstly it’s interesting to note that the software is not entirely free (which in my opinion is good news.) Most personal bloggers…

  20. Ack! I can’t believe MT 3 still uses b, i and u tags! When I upgrade, my first hack will be to change b to strong, i to em and remove u completely.

  21. Hmmm, how come it looks like crap in Firefox for me!?
    See!

  22. Shaky: Hold down the shift key while you reload in Firefox and all will be well, I’ll bet. That’s what happened w/me in Safari, as well, and it was just a cache issue.

  23. Tried the shift key. Maybe some manual deletion is required. I had never logged into MT from Firefox at work, so I just tried it and it looks perfect.

  24. upgraded to movable type 3.0

    I looked at some screencaps of Movable Type 3.0 and finally decided to upgrade. The old Movable Type systems were really a pain – all those little images reloading every time you used it – but MT3.0 has a CSS-based menu as…

  25. Blogs

    Its now 3pm sharp as I was looking at the time and editing this site. Ive added another link to my sister’s boyfriends site. Its called ‘Kenny’s Blog’ over at the left hand side under the links section. Although I…